The Sharing Gap
Show notes
Key Takeaways
- The useful stuff — the how, the practice, the messy learnings — is disappearing from social media, crowded out by platitudes and AI slop.
- Leaders are sitting on great work but won’t share it, convinced everyone else is further ahead and their own story is “too small” or “too niche.”
- Even an “unglamorous” result is valuable — e.g., “we tried 20 things, it was different work but no efficiency gains” is a learning others need.
- It’s imposter syndrome at the product level: like every team certain a competitor does it better, we’re too close to our own work to see what’s interesting.
- Teresa’s fix: stop writing generic guides and share only what you’re personally doing — specificity and a real point of view are what differentiate you now.
- Personal, specific stories consistently outperform platitudes — humans react to lived experience, not AI slop.
- Try the 5-day challenge: each day, pick the most interesting thing that happened and post it. Most posts get ignored (so it’s low-risk), and you build the habit.
- No matter where you are, someone’s a step behind you — write for them. Describe what you faced, what you did, and what you hope happens; you don’t need the ending.
Notable Moments
- “We need to get into the how — what are you putting into practice? That’s the stuff that’s valuable to share.” — Teresa
- “I would encourage people to share more — even if it’s unfinished, even if it’s small — and not just leave the field to the thought leaders.” — Petra
- “I made a very deliberate decision: I’m only going to write about things that I am personally doing.” — Teresa
- “When we write platitudes and AI slop, humans don’t react to it. Share your personal experience — that’s what we want to read.” — Teresa
- “There’s always going to be someone a step ahead of you. But there’s also always someone a step behind you. So write for the person that’s a step behind.” — Teresa
Resources & Links:
- Follow Teresa Torres: https://ProductTalk.org
- Follow Petra Wille: https://Petra-Wille.com
Mentioned in this episode:
- Petra Wille Product Coaching Packages
- Mind the Product (MTP) — mentioned as a place to publish and share product writing
- Brian Chesky of Airbnb’s user-journey / storytelling video — Petra’s go-to example of grounded, screen-based business storytelling
- Listener call-out — Petra and Teresa invite you to send real, substantial, grounded examples of product work their way
- Product meetups / Product Tank — Petra’s and Teresa’s examples (Portland included) of lower-stakes places to share
- April Dunford’s Positioning and Pessimistic Product Thinking — her blog post on why teams always believe their own product isn’t very good
- What Teresa writes about now: Claude Code, and a year of building AI evals — the basis for her recent posts
- The 5-day LinkedIn challenge — the simple practice introduced in this episode
Show transcript
00:00:03: Hi folks, this is all
00:00:05: things
00:00:06: product with Petra Bille
00:00:07: and Theresa Kortz.
00:00:09: And we're so happy
00:00:10: you here!
00:00:16: Petra... We are going to revisit something that was talked about before which it's the never-ending challenge of social media.
00:00:23: and what share on social media AI sloping our own strategies.
00:00:28: but I think like i want tackle from a trend standpoint.
00:00:35: It's getting harder and harder to convince people, to share their real stories.
00:00:39: And that instead like... People are posting like I'm just gonna call them platitudes Like Talk To Your Customers More!
00:00:47: Yeah great let's talk about That.
00:00:50: one thing.
00:00:50: i talked a lot but like.. That is not helpful.
00:00:53: we all know
00:00:54: that
00:00:54: We need to get into the how.
00:01:00: How Are You Doing This?
00:01:01: What do you put it in practice?
00:01:03: This is the stuff that's valuable to share.
00:01:06: But it sounds like you're hearing a lot of resistance to this, and so maybe we could just unpack this a little bit?
00:01:10: Oh yeah thanks for bringing that topic!
00:01:15: Yeah, so just to give a bit of context for the people who are not regular listeners So I do product leadership coaching day in and out.
00:01:23: So i talk to cpo's heads off product team leads.
00:01:27: That's the folks that am working with.
00:01:28: they're running a product organization.
00:01:29: They're managing product managers.
00:01:31: They overlook their overseas portfolio The oversea portfolio strategy or product strategies kind of things right?
00:01:38: And In the past At least in my little sample bubble, it was easier if I saw in coaching something amazing.
00:01:47: A very good product strategy or a very well-shaped opportunity solution tree or a prototype...a click prototype long on extra click prototypes.
00:01:59: that really was amazing!
00:02:02: It was rather easy for me to convince them to either talk about it at a meetup because were more low-key.
00:02:11: So just like people went there, they weren't even thinking about what their word is when after work and you had a beer somebody said who's hiring?
00:02:20: And then three talks.
00:02:22: two of them are very mediocre.
00:02:25: one was cool but came for networking anyways right so that meetups back in the day People attended didn't hesitate to share unfinished ideas or show the works at least from my, all the product tanks that I saw and i think have quite a sample on the planet.
00:02:46: That's what they were in the beginning.
00:02:47: so it was product people talking about products stuff and sharing their work.
00:02:56: A similar thing was me convincing them to blog, write a blog post about something and maybe reach out to MTP meant the product.
00:03:04: And publish it on their blog or I sometimes help my client put it in my blog if they didn't know where to put it.
00:03:11: company block.
00:03:13: there was big things as well because companies were concerned of employer branding.
00:03:18: so it's cool for somebody talk how cool the product department is working no longer.
00:03:24: I still see very cool things in my coaching, Very Cool Things.
00:03:31: In particular how product leaders put their entire product operating system and they're entire.
00:03:37: hey this is how i want you to work with me!
00:03:40: In an AI Operating System so that people could actually understand How They Want a Particular a session to be structured, meeting to be held.
00:03:51: A PowerPoint deck to beat whatever right?
00:03:53: So there is a lot of how we collaborate stuff that I see and then there's a lot.
00:03:59: Hey this is how we optimize discovery the cool versions of it but everybody seems so reluctant sharing.
00:04:08: because hey thats what i hear.
00:04:12: im not sharing other companies the front runners, they're well ahead.
00:04:18: They doing fancier stuff better stuff.
00:04:21: and how does it look if I share my small story?
00:04:25: My small use case because It's just a very niche thing that we saw.
00:04:29: Yes!
00:04:29: It is working Well here.
00:04:31: but frankly speaking all The other AI stuff We haven't yet figured out...we do A lot of things differently But there are no efficiency gains.
00:04:39: so That's the kind Of Things that i'm hearing a Lot.
00:04:45: But isn't even that a cool learning to say like, hey look.
00:04:48: That's the twenty things we tried and all of it required us work different but it was just same amount of hours.
00:04:57: It was no efficiency gains.
00:05:01: Even that would be an amazing learning maybe for others To hear because if you put out Then people start to disagree.
00:05:08: People started to build on it again, at least in the past.
00:05:12: now if you put stuff on LinkedIn and that's what some of my product leaders say as well yeah I just recently put something on LinkedIn And all i get is AI slop comments from random folks That I never have heard off!
00:05:27: So its not so rewarding To share something.
00:05:31: somehow this entire cycle Is broken.
00:05:37: What in midterm that will mean for all of us and the craft, And.
00:05:43: The community and the learning anti upskilling?
00:05:47: Yeah because even I'm not a big fan of Francesca we have to say this.
00:05:52: but Airbnb For example has so many real life work examples out there.
00:05:57: they Have these amazing user journey That you still could watch.
00:06:00: it's an Amazing video.
00:06:01: maybe We can put It into show notes Where I always can explain to people why business storytelling really matters and where it does not have to be super high level.
00:06:10: It can still be based on screens, And that is a video where every CEO in every company would say like yeah exactly!
00:06:17: That's what i want.
00:06:18: go build
00:06:18: it!!
00:06:19: I'm glad you already did all your discovery.
00:06:22: ,I am glad that you already do de-risking..i totally understand Why You are building this particular product.
00:06:31: I haven't seen anything like that.
00:06:33: And please, if listeners have seen something that is very substantial real helpful and grounded send it our way happy to share all of these things.
00:06:53: worrying.
00:06:54: So I would encourage people to share more, even if it's unfinished or small stuff and things that just helps them personally And not leave the field for thought leaders and agency and consultants because what we do is rather artificial.
00:07:12: Of course there are values in me sharing with my different clients as well But i'd love to see more hands-on examples of product work.
00:07:23: Yeah, okay.
00:07:24: I have a lot of thoughts on this.
00:07:26: i'm gonna go all the way back to when.
00:07:27: that's
00:07:27: why we brought The topic
00:07:29: yeah?
00:07:30: I ran a product tank in portland for several years.
00:07:34: It was not easy to find speakers
00:07:36: Mm-hmm.
00:07:37: I had big mediocre dogs.
00:07:39: Yeah, I did beg people and People but people that didn't want to speak wanted to speak about things That We would call AI slot today.
00:07:48: They Wanted To Speak About Like A platitude that they just generalized with no personal story whatsoever.
00:07:56: And so I spent a lot of time recruiting
00:07:58: them there,
00:08:00: coaching speakers trying to get them to share their actual work and So i think i have A little bit Of insight into why this is hard for people?
00:08:09: I Think They.
00:08:09: i think you're right.
00:08:10: i think they do think They're behind and they don't want To show That they are Behind.
00:08:18: I added
00:08:20: sometimes a different story.
00:08:22: Yeah,
00:08:23: they're worried about.
00:08:23: am i allowed to share this?
00:08:24: Um...I think when we are in the work it's really hard To see what is interesting About their work.
00:08:37: So its not just that They feel behind.
00:08:39: Its like The thing Their doing they don't Think Is Interesting.
00:08:42: But my product leaders Usually Are Not Doing Their Work.
00:08:45: They Observing Their Teams Doing Their Works so They Could See
00:08:50: Yeah, but I think they're too close to it.
00:08:55: It's still wrapped up.
00:08:56: in this sphere of like...it's why every product team thinks their competitors are better than them.
00:09:03: They could be leading!
00:09:04: They can be LEADING IN THE MARKET And i guarantee everybody on the product team has an opinion about something that their competitor does better.
00:09:11: April Dunford wrote a blog post about this..I forget what she called it But She Has A Term For This.
00:09:18: your product just isn't very good.
00:09:21: And everybody believes this about their own products, it's a little bit like imposter syndrome applied to the product level right?
00:09:27: I love it.
00:09:28: yeah
00:09:29: true.
00:09:29: and so i think... It keeps
00:09:31: us motivated on our toes.
00:09:34: Yeah!
00:09:35: We have to take risk.
00:09:39: So two years ago I started to notice social media was turning into AI slop.
00:09:48: I was getting really frustrated by people that didn't have expertise starting to write about topics, which is fine.
00:09:55: People can write about discovery all they want.
00:09:59: but it made me question what value could i bring from the fact?
00:10:08: now its very easy for anybody on this planet do anything related to discovery that's already been discussed for the last twenty years.
00:10:20: So like, am I adding value by writing and sharing about those things?
00:10:23: No it has already written!
00:10:25: And frankly...like..I don't have more to say on that because i'm kind of bored talking about all this stuff.
00:10:29: And so....i made a very deliberate decision- I AM ONLY GOING TO SHARE AND WRITE ABOUT THINGS THAT I AM PERSONALLY DOING.
00:10:42: And this
00:10:43: is why, like I started writing about cloud code.
00:10:44: It's because i was spending all of my time in cloud code!
00:10:48: Yeah but
00:10:48: if people would be doing that it will be amazing...
00:10:51: ...I started writing abou AI eVals and its not the new hot topic.
00:10:55: If I were to write about it Because it wasn't a new Hot Topic I woud've written about last summer.
00:11:00: I wrote about it A month ago Two months ago Because..
00:11:05: There was a right timing too?
00:11:05: ..I now
00:11:06: have year Of experience creating Eval after eval and I have a point of view, And i'm writing about my experience.
00:11:16: I am not writing the generic AI eval guide.
00:11:23: Because to me it was not invented for that... It was a big part of what motivated all of us to work in that realm, is that we believed and this sharing is caring.
00:11:42: We can learn from each other now.
00:11:44: finally as the people Can actually share What do?
00:11:49: That's where open source Is coming From To some extent.
00:11:53: so it Was always important to Do The Work To Talk About the Work To Share What We Learned And Help Others.
00:12:00: Basically Stand On the stuff that has worked for us, however you would put it.
00:12:07: But do we still believe in that?
00:12:09: Have we managed to give that legacy to the new generation of leaders?
00:12:14: should we do that more is maybe not our thing.
00:12:17: shall we just retire and move ourselves from the internet?
00:12:22: what are we doing?
00:12:23: Are We Still Valuing The Sharing?
00:12:25: Teresa?
00:12:26: I think we are And the reason why i think When I shifted strategy, everything i've done since has performed way better.
00:12:35: Yeah, it's because we're tired of platitudes like share your personal experience.
00:13:02: That's what you want to read.
00:13:04: and
00:13:04: I think the reason why this is hard.
00:13:06: Is its requires being vulnerable.
00:13:08: It requires taking a little bit of a risk And so like what
00:13:12: it requires you to take the time to sit down, write a blog post.
00:13:16: I know not everybody is great at writing these days.
00:13:19: recorded video these days.
00:13:20: go to meet up.
00:13:21: still there's still thing.
00:13:22: i think they will become even more of things in the future because all of us are craving human connection.
00:13:27: So I think their various formats that people could use To talk about their personal story and shadow means smaller or bigger target groups and audiences.
00:13:36: You knew What here?
00:13:37: Is what I would recommend?
00:13:38: I Think That Like It's A Little Bit Scary I would say do a five-day challenge, like Monday through Friday.
00:13:45: Pick at the end of the day.
00:13:47: pick one thing that happened in that day That you think was the most interesting thing of your day and write about it on LinkedIn.
00:13:56: Do that for five days.
00:13:58: And here's what i think is going to happen?
00:13:59: I think most of the time It's gonna get completely ignored because Most things from linkedin get totally ignored
00:14:05: so my mom might like it.
00:14:07: nobody's Gonna see it.
00:14:08: it's not that scary.
00:14:09: it's About building the muscle.
00:14:11: And I think the reason why would do it for five days, if you can do it two weeks even better.
00:14:15: Five days ten days there's a high chance that at least one of things to write about is going to resonate with people and your gonna get a handful comments.
00:14:24: some likes and you're gonna be surprised by thing didn't was interesting really interesting.
00:14:31: other people so like yes i guess those blockers who are behind or not allowed share this stuff.
00:14:40: Try to find one thing every day and just experiment because they're all no matter where you are on your journey Literally, no matter.
00:14:50: Where you aren't in your journey there's somebody a step behind You.
00:14:54: yes
00:14:55: There is always gonna be someone.
00:14:56: I step ahead of you right that's fine Yeah?
00:14:58: They will always be someone a step ahead
00:15:00: at you yeah
00:15:01: But there's also always going to be some other step behind you.
00:15:03: so right for the person.
00:15:05: that's a step behind you and You can literally think about it.
00:15:09: That way, you can at the end of your day Think about what was the most interesting thing that happened today?
00:15:14: Now I'm gonna imagine another product team is about to face this themselves.
00:15:18: What would i tell them?
00:15:20: Yeah, right?
00:15:20: That's
00:15:21: an amazing coaching framing for exactly that exercise.
00:15:25: And
00:15:25: don't write it as a general rule.
00:15:28: always do this.
00:15:29: never
00:15:32: Do what I know.
00:15:33: mountain biking taught me about product management just
00:15:37: like I ran into something interesting today.
00:15:40: Here's what we were facing, and you can generalize a little bit if you can't share the proprietary details.
00:15:45: Mm-hmm here is What We Did And Here Is How It Worked Out.
00:15:48: Or Here'S What We did And Here'S That We're Hoping Will Happen.
00:15:51: You Don'T Even Have To Know If it's Going to Work out or Not?
00:15:53: You Could Just Describe The Thinking Behind It!
00:15:56: I would like to add think about niche topics because maybe in your country there is something that's currently a topic in software development, product development whatever.
00:16:09: In the particular industry even.
00:16:11: and then please just talk about it because if anything is niche other people are having similar challenge.
00:16:19: maybe they might be landing down the line.
00:16:23: Yeah I think we probably know this almost all of our things.
00:16:30: There's gonna be people better than us, there're going to me not as far along
00:16:34: is us.
00:16:35: I think Vicky has just remembered that it worked too.
00:16:37: like look around your company.
00:16:38: you probably feel the way about another product manager in your company.
00:16:41: might a little bit better then you or other product manager of your company maybe further behind them and their career.
00:16:48: That same everywhere.
00:16:50: so right for person.
00:16:51: one step back.
00:16:53: Yes thats perfect sentence to close this episode.
00:16:57: Thank You so much Teresa.
00:16:59: As always
00:17:00: Thanks, Patrick.
New comment